|

REFF Critiquers:
D.
Laine
Nicole
Eng
Keiiii
|
Final Fantasy VI Fanart: Kefka
Artwork by Gemini
|
|
Personal website: http://www.geocities.com/cartoonempress
Specialty in Art: People
Specialty in Medium: CG
Self-estimated level: Intermediate
Artist's Comments: Umm I dunno. This is the work I'm most
proud of, so I want to know how I can draw even better than this.
^_^ Oo, and I just hate the fact that I can't draw noses! I've been
trying for years and I just can't find a way to draw noses. I don't
want to make them too anime-ish, or too realistic. *pout* Wah! Also,
you can criticize anything else you see, too. And.. *thinks* oh
yes, I can't draw clothes at all.. Help me! ^^;
|

Laine Says: hello ! don't worry , i draw with my plain ol' mechnical
pencils too and they work fine :D if u want something more...complex than
that , my best advice would be to try all of them out ! markers , gouache
, acrylics , watercolors , all of em ! as for noses...a mix between anime
and realism would be Takehiko noses ( he did Slamdunnk and Musashi ) and
Kunihiko noses ( Key the Metal Idol and Xenogears ) , they look real ,
but not too anime-ish in the sense they have holes and not just a black
trinagle ^^x . okay , back to picture ! very nice moood in the picture
, u really made it look like she's at peace ^^ what i would recommend
would be to make the shades darker in some shadows already darkened to
add more defination to the picture :D for a more realistic nose , perhaps
some shading to show the bridge of her nose ? also , her hair needs to
have more..variety in it :D variety is the spice of art , have some hair
going here , some there , some curling over some more hair at the bottom
, like theres lots of layers of hair ! lastly , her clothes..hm....only
thing i can say about this is to look at more clothing and practice drwaing
...looking at reference pics helps a lot too ^^gambare !
[ Back ]
Nicole Eng Says: Over all, I feel you really do have a lot of talent
and a good sense of style. The drawing is quite nice already; the image
is pleasant and the figure has an interesting expression. Keep drawing!
You've alot of time to perfect your style. ^_^ about tech details: On
first inspection, one aspect pops out - the lines are too light and there
isn't enough contrast in the image, probably because of a faulty scan.
You can correct this in any photo editing program (Microsoft Photo Editor
works well) by adjusting the Brightness/Contrast. about pose/proportions:
I really like the choice of angle - I don't really see an upside down
image too often. On a whole, things look okay - things are all in the
right location. The arms and torso are the right size and placement, but
the head looks a bit big for the rest of the parts. However, the facial
structures are lined up in the right locations, good job! And about detail:
While you have alot of detail in the clothing and body, you seem to have
skimped on the details in the face. Whether or not this is intended, I
do recommend that you attempt to define the facial structures more strongly
to balance it with the rest of the image. Some directional shading would
help immensely. On the hair - I like how you've decided to fan the hair
out into the background. The radial lines draw the eye to the center where
the face is - a very nice touch. However, as it is, the lines are a bit
too straight and the shape of the head is lost. When they fan out, the
strands of hair should curve around the contour of the head before going
into the straight lines. Make sure to have the hair that lies on top of
the head curve down; where the head ends and the hair attaches, you can
continue the straighter lines.
[ Back ]
Keiiii Says: You know, regular pencils (not mechanical) are actually
very good mediums. They can be used skillfully to create some really cool
stuff ^o^ I think you could've made the shadings darker in some parts
to make the picture stand out. That's one thing that I always keep in
mind when shading with pencil: be bold! ^-^ Now, the face. She has this
beautiful, not-too-innocent-yet-not-so-sinister look. Good job on that!
Although it seems that long eyes are your style, you might want to try
giving a little more space between the eyes. In reality, there is enough
space for another eye between two eyes. About the nose, you really have
to define what you call "too anime" with it. There are some styles where
all you find about the nose is a little... inkling about it (Dragon Ball
Z, for example), which I consider too anime (note: too anime does NOT
mean bad). Try imitating some styles that aren't strictly anime, such
as Romancing SaGa/SaGa Frontier artworks and Soukaigi artworks, perhaps?
And while you did do her hair really nice, longer lines rather than choppy
short lines plus stronger shading would be nice IMO. ^_^
|