Header image
      "Drawing is like ... kung fu, yeah?!" — Evil Tiger  

The Critique Corner

Summoners from Final Fantasy Tactics
" Summoners "
Pencil and PS5 artwork by Jesse Shepherd

Evaluators:

  Hanna Chen
  Lorelai Wu
  Silas McLeere
  Sandara-3


-- feedback from the forces --

Hanna's PictureHanna Says:Wonderful drawing! I love the special effect and colours, as well as the settle expressions on the two characters faces. There are two things, however, that seems a little odd. The top of the two character's hair looks as if they're in the shadows, yet there's a bright light in the centre. (the lens flare... ^^) If that's a separate light source, there should be some sort of reflection on the hair, i.e. highlights. The other thing is, the character's eyes looks like eyes viewed from the front, for profile views, the eye should be shorter. The lens flare creates very nice effect for the drawing, but I think it's a little too bright that it draws away viewer's attention and they miss beauty of the original drawing! And because it's places up high on the drawing, viewers are likely to pay less attention to the bottom of the piece. Other than that, this drawing is a very well-done!

[ back to top ]


Lorelai's Picture Lorelai Says: Man, you really have to keep up the fanart, because I can tell you've got a mind for the most awesome ideas! This post really hits me, it's so profound! The lens flare is well-placed too. However, it's time to work on your human profiles! The human profile is not so flat and square. the nose is taller than you think, and the eyes lower than you think. Of course, ethnicity also matters, but either way, I think it's time to get out that sketchbook, sit on a park bench, and observe!!! Good Luck!

[ back to top ]


Lorelai's Picture Silas Says: Ah, a summoner. The Knights have Cecil and Cyan and what not as their figurehead, and the summoner's have.... um... well.... Rydia? I guess I won't go on my Rydia-bashing spree on my first critique. I'll save it for later. :D The almost complete lack of white gives the drawing a more complete look to it, and the shading is done quite well. The ONLY problem I have with it is the lens flare, a wonderful tool that's used way too much for the wrong reasons. While this isn't exactly the wrong reason, it's not used to enchance the image, just to make it look prettier. If the picture was symbolic, it might have been more appropriate to have an image of a summoned monster or something. Not to say this drawing needs reworking. Just trying to give sound advice. :D

[ back to top ]


Sandara's Picture Sandara-3 Says: hi Jesse! great job using PS5...^_^ and nice composition. your coloring is pretty good already, and the only thing you need to work on now is your inking. use long strokes instead of short jagged "furry" lines.

[ back to top ]





[ Back ]      

----------------

© 1999-2001 The Art Corner and REFFs

The design/contents of this Web site may not be used/reproduced
without prior permission from the REFFs.

For our complete copyright info/disclaimer, click here.